In a column published across multiple News Corp mastheads, Andrew Johns — one of the game's most respected commentators — has dramatically rowed back on his earlier assessment of the Roosters' title credentials. "It would have been madness to suggest just five days ago, but I can now see a world where the Roosters don’t make the top four, let alone the grand final," Johns wrote.
While Johns did not specify the exact trigger for his changed view, the timing suggests recent on-field performances or off-field developments have soured his confidence. The Roosters, under coach Trent Robinson, have been perennial contenders in recent years, but injuries, form slumps, or tactical deficiencies may have emerged as red flags.
Johns is known for his forthright analysis, and his words carry weight among fans and pundits alike. However, his view is not universally shared. Several other commentators have pointed to the Roosters' depth and big-game experience as reasons to remain bullish. The betting markets have only marginally shifted, indicating uncertainty rather than panic.
The Roosters themselves have not publicly responded to Johns' remarks, but internally the squad will be focused on controlling what they can: winning their remaining regular-season matches. A loss in the coming round could further fuel doubts, while a decisive victory would silence critics.
For readers, this serves as a reminder how quickly narratives can change in sport. It also highlights the intense scrutiny placed on teams with championship aspirations. The Roosters face a crucial test next weekend that may define their season.