Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has rowed back on plans for care workers to wait 15 years for permanent settlement, offering an estimated 280,000 eligible care workers and their dependants a five-year route. She said the standard qualifying period for most migrants would double to 10 years, with many already in the UK facing longer waits under rules announced on Monday.
Announcing the final outcome of a year-long consultation that drew more than 200,000 responses, Mahmood told the Commons that care workers earning at least £25,000 a year who arrived before May 2025 would continue to qualify for indefinite leave to remain (ILR) after five years, a concession to pressure from health unions, cabinet colleagues including Housing Secretary Angela Rayner, and backbench Labour MPs.
The original plans, drawn up last November under Sir Keir Starmer's government, would have forced workers in occupations below degree level to wait up to 15 years for settlement, with 117,000 low-paid care workers and their 79,000 dependants affected. The Home Office had estimated the net lifetime cost of care workers and their adult dependants settling between 2026 and 2030 at £10bn under current rules.
The revised package retains most of the other tough measures. The standard qualifying period for most migrants doubles to 10 years. People who arrived by small boat or other irregular routes face up to 30 years before they can apply. Refugees entering legally but not through designated safe routes will wait 10 years if they work or study, and 20 years if they do not; refugees who arrived illegally and do not work or study will wait 30 years.
Under the new model, high earners on more than £125,000 a year can settle in three years. Those earning above £50,271, and some public service workers such as doctors, nurses and teachers, will qualify after five years. About 100,000 skilled workers including butchers and chefs will wait 10 years, officials said.
The Home Office calculates 517,000 people already in the UK will now face longer waits, down from 799,000 under the original plan. Migrants who have claimed certain benefits or breached immigration rules face at least 20 years.
Mahmood told the BBC the changes overall represented “savings in the billions” to the Department for Work and Pensions. She declined to specify the cost of the revised plans, saying detailed costs would be published when the department puts the changes before Parliament.
The retrospective application of the new rules to migrants already in the UK drew criticism. Labour MP for Sheffield Central, Abtisam Mohamed, called it unfair, while former shadow home secretary Diane Abbott warned of another potential Windrush scandal. The Law Society said it “retrospectively undermines the legal certainty that individuals, families and employers rely on”.
Migrant rights organisations accused the government of "moving the goalposts". Amnesty International said: "People who have built their lives around the government's requirements deserve better than decisions that turn their own and their families' lives upside down."
Conservatives and Reform UK labelled the revised plans a U-turn. Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said Mahmood had been “forced to surrender” to the “open borders Labour left” and that the exemption would cost billions. Reform UK leader Nigel Farage called it “the beginning of the capitulation”.
The Unison general secretary, Andrea Egan, welcomed the climbdown from what she called "morally bankrupt" original plans, but said the obligations on care workers to qualify remained onerous. Business groups warned that retrospective changes would still damage retention of skilled workers.
Some Conservative MPs acknowledged the previous Tory government had allowed legal migration numbers to rise sharply. Backbencher Edward Leigh told the shadow home secretary that "anybody who was serving as a Home Office minister at that time should wear sackcloth and ashes".
The new rules are due to come into effect next year. They do not require a vote in Parliament, limiting MPs' ability to block them.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The changes affect hundreds of thousands of migrants already living and working in the UK, many of whom arrived expecting to qualify for settlement after five years
- The care-worker exemption spares an estimated 280,000 people a 15-year wait, but the retrospective doubling of wait times for other workers creates uncertainty for employers and families
- The policy signals a significant shift in the UK's immigration settlement system from time-based to contribution-based, with implications for sectors reliant on migrant labour
Background
The proposals stem from concern over record post-Brexit net migration, particularly the wave of legal arrivals dubbed the "Boriswave" under Boris Johnson's premiership, who are now approaching the current five-year settlement threshold. Mahmood initially set out the overhaul in November 2025, proposing to double qualifying periods and create a 15-year pathway for lower-paid workers. The consultation attracted more than 200,000 responses. A public backlash from within the Labour Party, including from Housing Secretary Angela Rayner, who called the retrospective application "un-British", led to the softening for care workers.
Key Perspectives
Shabana Mahmood (Home Secretary): said the revised package "strikes the right balance" and that settlement was one of the most valuable rights the country can offer, which "must be earned". She argued the changes would save billions in benefits.
Conservatives and Reform UK: Chris Philp said the U-turn would cost billions, while Nigel Farage called it "the beginning of the capitulation". Reform UK has pledged to scrap indefinite leave to remain and replace it with a five-year renewable work visa.
Labour MPs: Abtisam Mohamed called retrospective changes unfair; Diane Abbott warned of another Windrush; Stella Creasy said thousands faced "10 years of limbo" with economic consequences.
Unison (Andrea Egan): welcomed the climbdown but said obligations placed on care workers remained onerous, and called for an end to employers' power to threaten workers' settlement.
Amnesty International: accused the government of "moving the goalposts" for people who had played by the rules.
The Law Society: said retrospective changes "undermine legal certainty" and threaten the rule of law.
Business groups (CBI, Make UK): warned retrospective changes would still cause damage, with Make UK saying industries would "undoubtedly lose talent to countries that welcome skilled workers".
What to Watch
- The detailed cost analysis the Home Office has promised to publish when the changes are formally laid before Parliament
- Whether Labour MPs who opposed the retrospective changes will continue to press for amendments, despite the changes not requiring a parliamentary vote
- The impact on sectors reliant on migrant workers, particularly care homes, hospitality and manufacturing, as the new rules take effect next year
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 4 sources: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedSome care workers are spared a 15-year wait while most migrants face tougher settlement rules.World news | The Guardian: “Shabana Mahmood rowed back on her most hardline plans to make care workers wait 15 years for settlement in the UK, but told MPs on Monday that many migrants would still face retrospective rule changes to make them wait a decade.”
- SupportedThe standard pathway is 10 years after cabinet backlash, and retrospective changes have drawn criticism.World news | The Guardian: “Under pressure from a cabinet backlash and health unions, the home secretary has offered a carve-out for care workers to allow them to apply for indefinite leave to remain after five years.”
- SupportedThe Law Society said the changes “retrospectively undermine[] the legal certainty that individuals, families and employers rely on”.World news | The Guardian: “The Law Society said the changing rules could threaten the rule of law, saying it “retrospectively undermines the legal certainty that individuals, families and employers rely on”.”
- SupportedAmnesty International said: “People who have built their lives around the government's requirements deserve better than decisions that turn their own and their families' lives upside down.”World news | The Guardian: ““People who have built their lives around the government’s requirements deserve better than decisions that turn their own and their families’ lives upside down,” said Amnesty International.”
- SupportedChris Philp said Mahmood had been “forced to surrender” to the “open borders Labour left”.The Independent UK: ““It's clear Shabana Mahmood has been forced to surrender to Angela Rayner and the open borders Labour left.””
- SupportedAn estimated 280,000 care workers and their dependants are offered a five-year route.World news | The Guardian: “the home secretary has moved to allow an estimated 280,000 care workers and their dependents to apply for indefinite leave to remain after five years.”
- SupportedThe consultation drew more than 200,000 responses over about a year.The Independent UK: “The proposals drew more than 200,000 responses in a nearly year-long consultation.”
- SupportedThe original plan would have made 117,000 low-paid care workers and 79,000 dependants wait up to 15 years.UK news | The Guardian: “Her earlier plans would have meant that 117,000 low-paid care workers and their 79,000 dependants would have to wait up to 15 years to receive indefinite leave to remain.”
- SupportedThe Home Office estimated the net lifetime cost of care workers and adult dependants settling from 2026 to 2030 at £10bn under existing rules.BBC News: “the net lifetime cost of care workers and their adult dependants expected to settle between 2026 and 2030 was estimated at £10bn under existing rules.”
- SupportedRefugees who enter legally but not through designated safe routes wait 10 years if they work or study and 20 years if they do not; those arriving illegally wait 30 years if they do not work or study.BBC News: “other refugees will need to wait 10 years and either work or study. Those who do not work or study will need to wait 20 years. Refugees who arrived in the UK by small boat or another illegal route will have to wait 20 years if they work or study, and 30 years if they don't.”
- SupportedMahmood told the BBC the changes represented “savings in the billions” to the Department of Work and Pensions.BBC News: “She said the changes overall represented "savings in the billions" to the Department of Work and Pensions in people not claiming benefits.”
- SupportedThe new rules will affect 517,000 people already in the UK with longer waits, down from 799,000 under the original plan.BBC News: “Under Monday's changes, this figure drops to 517,000. The original plans would have delayed 799,000 people from gaining permanent residency.”